Division of Electronics, Detectors and Computing for Physics (DEDIP)

What are magnetars?

Stars are all born in the same way, within a molecular cloud, but do not end their lives in the same way. This depends on their mass. During their existence, the core of a star fuses increasingly heavier elements, producing enough energy to counterbalance the weight of the outer layers that continuously compress the star.

When a medium-mass star like the Sun runs out of hydrogen, its core compresses in an attempt to fuse heavier chemical elements. This step generates a lot of energy that blows the outer layers of the star. These layers expand into space, creating a planetary nebula, while the core becomes a white dwarf, gradually cooling and fading away. The death of a more massive star, at least eight times the mass of the Sun, is more cataclysmic. When its iron core, produced by the fusion of lighter elements, reaches a critical mass, it collapses upon itself abruptly. The compression is so strong that protons and electrons combine to form neutrons. This contraction generates a shock wave that expels the outer layers of the star in an explosion known as a supernova. The resulting object is an extremely dense neutron star. Within a radius of about ten kilometers, its mass is equivalent to that of the Sun!

Among the different manifestations of neutron stars, magnetars are distinguished by transient X-ray and gamma-ray emissions. These intense radiation bursts draw their energy from the dissipation of abnormally high magnetic fields. The measurement of the slowing down of their rotation period - induced by a magnetic braking effect - confirms this scenario. It is thus estimated that magnetars have a dipolar magnetic field of the order of 10¹⁵ Gauss (G), up to 1000 times stronger than the typical magnetic field of neutron stars. If the existence of these extreme magnetic fields is well established, their origin remains controversial.

Why study a new formation scenario?

Several scenarios attempt to explain how the magnetic field can amplify during the death of massive stars to give rise to the particularly high magnetic fields of neutron stars.

On  one hand, some theories propose that the magnetic field of magnetars is entirely determined by that of the iron core of the progenitor star. The magnetic field would be amplified through the conservation of the magnetic flux during the core collapse, whose initial magnetization remains however uncertain.

On the other hand, some scenarios lean towards an amplification during the very first seconds of the neutron star's life. Two promising dynamo mechanisms have been studied through numerical simulations by the supernovae team of the Astrophysics Department, CEA Paris-Saclay. The first mechanism involves convective motions inside the protoneutron star, while the second invokes an instability of a differentially rotating fluid in the presence of a magnetic field. However, both theories assume a rapid rotation of the iron core of the progenitor star. However, Recent asteroseismic observations have shown that the core of a dying star tends to rotate more slowly than predicted by the stellar evolution models.

These new results suggest that a sufficiently fast rotation is likely too rare to explain the formation of all magnetars, and justify the search for new scenarios.

Result of the new study

In this new scenario, researchers from the supernovae team at Dap and the Max Planck Institute suggest that the amplification of the magnetic field  in magnetars is due to the matter ejected during the star’s explosion. Some of this material remains gravitationally bound to the proto-neutron star, and eventually falls back onto its surface. This phenomenon is known as "fallback".

Since the accretion of this matter is asymmetric, it accelerates the rotation of the surface of the proto-neutron star, making it faster than the rotation of the internal layers. According to these researchers, this differential rotation promotes the development of a dynamo which had never been studied in the context of neutron stars: the Tayler-Spruit dynamo (see Figure 2).

To verify if this formation scenario is relevant for magnetars, the authors of this study developed a numerical model of this physical process by evolving a weak magnetic field over time, and for different speeds rotation of a newly formed proto-neutron star.And the results are consistent: the researchers find the expected intensity and structure of the magnetic field in magnetars, even with  slow rotation, unlike previous scenarios that required rotation three times faster. This new scenario is promising and complements the two others to explain the formation of the majority of magnetars, born in standard supernovae.
The research team is currently working on studying the Tayler-Spruit dynamo via 3D numerical simulations. These simulations are necessary to obtain precise description of the dynamo mechanism in three dimensions and thus to verify the validity of the proposed model.